Quote from "A Story from the Sand Dunes" (1859)

Registered motifs in this quote

"Life is a precious gift of love, almost too great to understand," said the wife. "And just to think that this fullness of bliss shall still increase and grow, in another life, throughout eternity. I can hardly conceive of it!"

"And it certainly also shows the arrogance of people," said her husband. "It really shows a terrible conceit when people persuade themselves to think they'll live forever – become as God! Were these not the words of the serpent, the master of lies?"

"You surely don't doubt that there is a life after this, do you?" asked his young wife, and it was as if a shadow passed through their sunlit thoughts for the first time.

"Faith promises it, I know, and the priests tell us it is so," said the young man. "But, happy as I am now, I feel and know that it is only pride, an arrogant thought that demands another life after this – an extension of this happiness. Haven't we been granted enough in this life, so that we could and should be satisfied?"

"Yes, that has been given us," said the young wife, "but how many thousands find this life a heavy trail! How many have been thrown into this world only to find poverty, shame, sickness, and misfortune! No, if there were no afterlife, the blessings on this earth would be too unequally divided – our God would not be a God of justice!"

"The beggar down on the street has pleasures just as dear to him as the king enjoys in his splendid palace," said the young man. "And what about the poor beast of burden that is beaten and starved and works itself to death? Doesn't it sense the bitterness of its miserable life? Why shouldn't it too demand an afterlife, and call it unfair that it wasn't granted the advantages of a higher creation?"

"Christ told us, 'In my Father's house are many mansions,' " answered the young wife. "The Kingdom of Heaven is as infinite as God's love. The animal is His creation too, and I don't believe that any single life will be lost, but that each will be granted the greatest share of happiness it is capable of receiving."

Registered motifs in this quote:

  1. Faith
  2. God
  3. God's Kingdom, heaven
  4. Jesus Christ
  5. Priest
  6. Tales about resurrection

Keywords: Man, woman, happiness, unhappiness, justice, meaning, discussion, theology, love

Comment: It is a recurring gender relationship in theological discussions in HCA's writings, that men doubt and women believe, see for example What Old Johanne Told. In this case, and this is typical as well, the question is about the immortality of the soul. He is in doubt, and he thinks that the thought of everlasting existence is an ungrateful and vain conception, because this life ought to be enough. Her counterargument is rationalistic-Christian: There must be life after death in order to put things right – there is injustice in this world, and some people suffer. The afterlife would let these people experience happiness on the other side of death's threshold. Otherwise the universe would be unjust, which cannot be assumed by rationalistic thinkers, because it s presumed that God is sensible and loving. Thus the Creation must be harmonic and suitable for His beings.